Pine cone owls- always love a good owl decoration - 20 Magical DIY Christmas Home Decorations You'll Want Right Now
DIY Game of Tic-Tac-Toe - a super cute twist to an ever enduring classic
Felt and pinecone elves
pinecone birds with acorn heads
Diy air dry clay trees, punch star shaped holes abd add a candle! // best of the web: air-dry clay projects
Kid's Craft: Pasta Ornaments (These are actually very unique & pretty! None of that elbow macaroni glued to a cardboard cutout & sprayed painted gold crap that they had me make as a kid! No Pattern or Instructions.
easy glitter bow garland from spray painted pasta
I know this isn't a Nativity, but I wonder if this concept would work for one - I love the items stuck in the top - a star and an angel would be just right up there.